{ "completedUTC": "2026-10-30T23:51:49.590552+00:00", "question": "Did the verified self-matches earn specific rewards or maker rebates?", "conclusion": "No causal reward or rebate attribution to the matched fills was established. Actual account-level payouts are verified, but the evidence does not support calling them rewards from those self-trades.", "strongestPositiveFacts": [ { "name": "Car", "type": "REWARD", "UTC": "2025-11-26T00:00:19+00:00", "APIAmount": "74.283", "incomingCanonicalTransfers": [ { "token": "0x2791bca1f2de4661ed88a30c99a7a9449aa84174", "from": "0xc288480574783bd7615170660d71753378159c47", "to": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "amount": "74.283", "rawAmount": "74283000", "logIndex": 629 } ], "transactionHash": "0xd946b812168687c331227cde468d5ea6cc708f8335c062b509ea6031deecb30a", "transactionStatus": "0x1", "outerTo": "0xca11bde05977b3631167028862be2a173976ca11", "outerSelector": "0x252dba42", "APIConditionId": "" }, { "name": "Car", "type": "REWARD", "UTC": "2025-09-13T00:00:11+00:00", "APIAmount": "165.9947", "incomingCanonicalTransfers": [ { "token": "0x2791bca1f2de4661ed88a30c99a7a9449aa84174", "from": "0xc288480574783bd7615170660d71753378159c47", "to": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "amount": "165.9947", "rawAmount": "165994700", "logIndex": 294 } ], "transactionHash": "0xdda0b65d02a0c8c3e99958fe389dc76dc19992deafc0f0203e0ca7dcbf9e4feb", "transactionStatus": "0x1", "outerTo": "0xca11bde05977b3631167028862be2a173976ca11", "outerSelector": "0x252dba42", "APIConditionId": "" }, { "name": "CarComboCup", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "UTC": "2026-01-09T00:03:52+00:00", "APIAmount": "12.0391", "incomingCanonicalTransfers": [ { "token": "0x2791bca1f2de4661ed88a30c99a7a9449aa84174", "from": "0x3a9418b2651c8164db5ebc56f12008137865e0f7", "to": "0x0690a02377f25f764a000aa385928f2a0142e540", "amount": "12.0391", "rawAmount": "12039100", "logIndex": 164 } ], "transactionHash": "0xc563175901657ce834cb7efbd02b764ae9c62553c474b8dd81adb3f7a56bfada", "transactionStatus": "0x1", "outerTo": "0xca11bde05977b3631167028862be2a173976ca11", "outerSelector": "0x252dba42", "APIConditionId": "" }, { "name": "kyskyskyskys", "type": "REWARD", "UTC": "2026-04-05T00:00:45+00:00", "APIAmount": "0.2987", "incomingCanonicalTransfers": [ { "token": "0x2791bca1f2de4661ed88a30c99a7a9449aa84174", "from": "0xf7cd89be08af4d4d6b1522852ced49fc10169f64", "to": "0xb39b8239a525a33579568a788193f6dc7e87b602", "amount": "0.2987", "rawAmount": "298700", "logIndex": 3372 } ], "transactionHash": "0xdc788e8cbcfeab8770b6deecd3d15c717cc78d3767407a7a58e0a69799bbc4de", "transactionStatus": "0x1", "outerTo": "0xf7cd89be08af4d4d6b1522852ced49fc10169f64", "outerSelector": "0x143ba4f3", "APIConditionId": "" }, { "name": "realmrbeast123", "type": "REWARD", "UTC": "2026-02-27T00:01:02+00:00", "APIAmount": "0.4524", "incomingCanonicalTransfers": [ { "token": "0x2791bca1f2de4661ed88a30c99a7a9449aa84174", "from": "0xf7cd89be08af4d4d6b1522852ced49fc10169f64", "to": "0xeb6a7f192f5c3e96c17e1436dd8f366372cfd67b", "amount": "0.4524", "rawAmount": "452400", "logIndex": 1951 } ], "transactionHash": "0x4dad605d85645df4f466c44c95839afe58212558cc99f8c7502023177ae6633c", "transactionStatus": "0x1", "outerTo": "0xf7cd89be08af4d4d6b1522852ced49fc10169f64", "outerSelector": "0x143ba4f3", "APIConditionId": "" } ], "feeEvidence": { "pairMakerEventFeeRawValues": [ "0" ], "actualOrderFeeRateBpsValues": [ 0 ], "makerEvents": 70, "actualUniqueOrders": 136 }, "rewardAPI": { "accounts": 9, "typeFilters": 18, "allQueriesSuccessfulAndTerminated": true, "summary": [ { "name": "Car", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 1136, "pages": 3, "firstTimestamp": 1708146533, "lastTimestamp": 1793318712, "totalReported": "98382.329725", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "Car", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 182, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1767916950, "lastTimestamp": 1793061924, "totalReported": "3588.8645", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "morongambler", "wallet": "0x15fe8f8eeaef262bc435e09206ea5d1540cb9cde", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "morongambler", "wallet": "0x15fe8f8eeaef262bc435e09206ea5d1540cb9cde", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "bigbrainUser", "wallet": "0xbbaef3583c059a96ce177507b1bc86a3ad477b24", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 33, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1754092804, "lastTimestamp": 1770163206, "totalReported": "230.7439", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "bigbrainUser", "wallet": "0xbbaef3583c059a96ce177507b1bc86a3ad477b24", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "b4k9xj2wh2", "wallet": "0x111b64194b29169259a70ae1b21209d73265bad9", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 62, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1743984005, "lastTimestamp": 1765929609, "totalReported": "629.0560", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "b4k9xj2wh2", "wallet": "0x111b64194b29169259a70ae1b21209d73265bad9", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "yagsimuraussob", "wallet": "0xe7baf7f38320d422501ee8566f0f3990fde26716", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "yagsimuraussob", "wallet": "0xe7baf7f38320d422501ee8566f0f3990fde26716", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "realmrbeast123", "wallet": "0xeb6a7f192f5c3e96c17e1436dd8f366372cfd67b", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 1, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1772150462, "lastTimestamp": 1772150462, "totalReported": "0.4524", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "realmrbeast123", "wallet": "0xeb6a7f192f5c3e96c17e1436dd8f366372cfd67b", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "flying-wheel", "wallet": "0x314896ba4dc34663fc8c283726ca6638ba1ebc30", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 4, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1774742428, "lastTimestamp": 1776988826, "totalReported": "6.8016", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "flying-wheel", "wallet": "0x314896ba4dc34663fc8c283726ca6638ba1ebc30", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 1, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1780533924, "lastTimestamp": 1780533924, "totalReported": "1.0454", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "kyskyskyskys", "wallet": "0xb39b8239a525a33579568a788193f6dc7e87b602", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 2, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1775260819, "lastTimestamp": 1775347245, "totalReported": "5.3314", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "kyskyskyskys", "wallet": "0xb39b8239a525a33579568a788193f6dc7e87b602", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "CarComboCup", "wallet": "0x0690a02377f25f764a000aa385928f2a0142e540", "type": "REWARD", "rows": 0, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": null, "lastTimestamp": null, "totalReported": "0", "conditionIds": [], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true }, { "name": "CarComboCup", "wallet": "0x0690a02377f25f764a000aa385928f2a0142e540", "type": "MAKER_REBATE", "rows": 1, "pages": 1, "firstTimestamp": 1767917032, "lastTimestamp": 1767917032, "totalReported": "12.0391", "conditionIds": [ "" ], "success": true, "endedWithShortPage": true } ], "allReturnedRewardAndRebateRowsHaveBlankConditionId": true, "boundary": "Complete returned API pagination for these filters, not an independent on-chain lifetime payout census." }, "b4ClosedLoopCase": { "loopDateUTC": "2025-11-25", "actualPayoutToCarNextMidnight": "74.283 USDC.e on 2025-11-26T00:00:19Z", "CarPayoutHasMarketOrOrderAttribution": false, "b4RewardRowsAroundLoop": "No API REWARD row between 2025-11-20 and 2025-12-02", "nearestB4APIRewardBeforeLoop": { "name": "b4k9xj2wh2", "wallet": "0x111b64194b29169259a70ae1b21209d73265bad9", "type": "REWARD", "timestamp": 1754092812, "UTC": "2025-08-02T00:00:12+00:00", "amount": "22.5035", "transactionHash": "0x97867448f900ed98749f7ee38d8abc1a9e1ddac46df07290dfc9a8c800e691df", "conditionId": "", "sourceURL": "https://data-api.polymarket.com/activity?user=0x111b64194b29169259a70ae1b21209d73265bad9&type=REWARD&limit=500&offset=0&sortBy=TIMESTAMP&sortDirection=ASC" }, "nearestB4APIRewardAfterLoop": { "name": "b4k9xj2wh2", "wallet": "0x111b64194b29169259a70ae1b21209d73265bad9", "type": "REWARD", "timestamp": 1765152023, "UTC": "2025-12-08T00:00:23+00:00", "amount": "1.2734", "transactionHash": "0xda409adaa174338821a69c66de4695b394ff6d7a12ac2f344df217e4dac1e357", "conditionId": "", "sourceURL": "https://data-api.polymarket.com/activity?user=0x111b64194b29169259a70ae1b21209d73265bad9&type=REWARD&limit=500&offset=0&sortBy=TIMESTAMP&sortDirection=ASC" }, "b4MakerRebateRowsReturned": 0, "assessment": "The actual fully closed self-match remains established. These reward records do not establish that the loop harvested rewards." }, "ComboTwelveLoopsCase": { "loopDateUTC": "2025-09-12", "actualPayoutToCarNextMidnight": "165.9947 USDC.e on 2025-09-13T00:00:11Z", "ComboAPIRewardRowsReturned": 0, "ComboOnlyAPIMakerRebate": "12.0391 USDC.e on 2026-01-09T00:03:52Z", "ComboPublicRebateAccrualRow": "2026-01-08, 12.039108 USDC, condition_id=0x aggregate placeholder; the later on-chain settlement is 12.0391. This observed small difference is not interpreted as wrongdoing.", "assessment": "No exact reward or rebate tie to the September 12 loops. January payment alone cannot be assigned to September trades." }, "publicHistoricalMakerRebateLookups": { "documentedURL": "https://docs.polymarket.com/programs/maker-rebates", "endpoint": "https://clob.polymarket.com/rebates/current", "queryCount": 124, "allHTTP200": true, "targetDateWalletQueries": 112, "targetConditions": 42, "nonemptyQueries": 14, "returnedEntries": 25, "exactTargetConditionMatches": 0, "unallocatedLegacyTargetRows": [ { "date": "2026-01-30", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "rebatedFeesUSDC": "3.416892", "targetConditions": [ "0x487b4d303237dda42cf73b69695181d7cf5cc3e71c9a4f710f0107358d0fab1f" ] }, { "date": "2026-02-01", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "rebatedFeesUSDC": "106.794664", "targetConditions": [ "0x05beef793157deb1cc34e2d3159539f461b73c7eeaa3b5348617c10eed5509d0" ] }, { "date": "2026-02-02", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "rebatedFeesUSDC": "5.164144", "targetConditions": [ "0x05beef793157deb1cc34e2d3159539f461b73c7eeaa3b5348617c10eed5509d0" ] }, { "date": "2026-02-12", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "rebatedFeesUSDC": "2.735946", "targetConditions": [ "0x348ade0c7df38c4fc23abb31eb7d74ee6bc7064dc0e2709a872be434857de1a9" ] }, { "date": "2026-02-16", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "rebatedFeesUSDC": "4.740527", "targetConditions": [ "0x62b15fe2609e034a700e0ec6bcc6565d234f2c17a4ecb648ad75a3f0f1b42449" ] }, { "date": "2026-02-17", "wallet": "0x7c3db723f1d4d8cb9c550095203b686cb11e5c6b", "rebatedFeesUSDC": "2.021343", "targetConditions": [ "0x62b15fe2609e034a700e0ec6bcc6565d234f2c17a4ecb648ad75a3f0f1b42449" ] } ], "positiveControlsReturnedRows": 4, "boundary": "No exact condition match found in these date/wallet queries. Legacy condition_id=0x rows cannot be allocated to a market and prevent a claim that all historical benefits are known to be zero." }, "retainedGammaMarketSettings": [ { "marketId": "695481", "question": "Israel strike on the West Bank by December 31?", "conditionId": "0xcaf7d1bdc9973a33a9b100ef99c2dd3d76aaa329c001ad5dddc3e5a64ec55561", "currentFeesEnabled": false, "currentRewardsMinSize": 0, "currentRewardsMaxSpread": 0, "retainedClobRewardRecords": [], "URL": "https://gamma-api.polymarket.com/markets/695481", "HTTP": 200, "historyBoundary": "Current Gamma records with retained configured start dates do not by themselves establish the exact reward settings or beneficiary scores at every historical point." }, { "marketId": "586138", "question": "EU sanctions on Israel by December 31?", "conditionId": "0xcc16cf145731cea7010e311de31a9fd0e5bd6103f40cd146187749f9673f6f4c", "currentFeesEnabled": false, "currentRewardsMinSize": 100, "currentRewardsMaxSpread": 3.5, "retainedClobRewardRecords": [], "URL": "https://gamma-api.polymarket.com/markets/586138", "HTTP": 200, "historyBoundary": "Current Gamma records with retained configured start dates do not by themselves establish the exact reward settings or beneficiary scores at every historical point." }, { "marketId": "573867", "question": "GTA 6 launch postponed?", "conditionId": "0x0241cf91983dfcfe654582499135a69a91948aca1bad9241ea9b6eaf56b37803", "currentFeesEnabled": false, "currentRewardsMinSize": 100, "currentRewardsMaxSpread": 3.5, "retainedClobRewardRecords": [ { "id": "31094", "conditionId": "0x0241cf91983dfcfe654582499135a69a91948aca1bad9241ea9b6eaf56b37803", "assetAddress": "0x2791Bca1f2de4661ED88A30C99A7a9449Aa84174", "rewardsAmount": 0, "rewardsDailyRate": 1, "startDate": "2025-08-08", "endDate": "2500-12-31" } ], "URL": "https://gamma-api.polymarket.com/markets/573867", "HTTP": 200, "historyBoundary": "Current Gamma records with retained configured start dates do not by themselves establish the exact reward settings or beneficiary scores at every historical point." }, { "marketId": "588004", "question": "Hypurr NFT airdrop by November 30?", "conditionId": "0xff8391163d782e495955ecc8cd7f2df6b5fe48a6c4a0eb5fd7ace76ef5d51705", "currentFeesEnabled": false, "currentRewardsMinSize": 50, "currentRewardsMaxSpread": 3.5, "retainedClobRewardRecords": [ { "id": "34074", "conditionId": "0xff8391163d782e495955ecc8cd7f2df6b5fe48a6c4a0eb5fd7ace76ef5d51705", "assetAddress": "0x2791Bca1f2de4661ED88A30C99A7a9449Aa84174", "rewardsAmount": 0, "rewardsDailyRate": 5, "startDate": "2025-09-04", "endDate": "2500-12-31" } ], "URL": "https://gamma-api.polymarket.com/markets/588004", "HTTP": 200, "historyBoundary": "Current Gamma records with retained configured start dates do not by themselves establish the exact reward settings or beneficiary scores at every historical point." } ], "accessAndAttributionGap": { "dailyUserEarningsURL": "https://clob.polymarket.com/rewards/user", "unauthenticatedHTTP": 401, "officialSDKRequiresL2": true, "unauthenticatedUserMarketEndpoint": "Returns maker_address=zero and zero earnings, not Car-specific historical earnings. The user query parameter is not evidence of account attribution.", "noAuthenticationBypassAttempted": true, "neededForStrongerClaim": "A legitimately obtained per-market historical reward statement, historical scored order-book snapshots or a first-party market/order attribution. Aggregate midnight payouts and fills alone do not supply this." }, "methodologySources": [ { "URL": "https://docs.polymarket.com/programs/liquidity-rewards", "summary": "Current program scores sampled resting orders and quote quality; executions alone do not reconstruct those historical scores." }, { "URL": "https://docs.polymarket.com/programs/maker-rebates", "summary": "Current program says fee-free fills earn no maker rebate and documents public historical maker-address lookups. The current rule text is not retroactively treated as a 2025 rule finding." }, { "URL": "https://github.com/Polymarket/clob-client/blob/main/src/client.ts", "summary": "Official client requires L2 account authentication for user daily earning and per-market earning methods." } ], "scopeLimits": [ "None of these findings adjudicates the self-match conduct or its purpose.", "No rewards fraud, specific airdrop gain or prohibited reward-credit benefit is claimed.", "The stronger existing conduct evidence is the independently closed b4 inventory/cash loop, separate from whether any reward accrued.", "Raw profile bios/images in local API responses must be omitted from any public selection; PUBLIC-REWARD-ROWS.json contains only financial fields.", "Current raw closed-market reward config endpoints returned empty; this is not evidence those markets never had historical liquidity rewards." ], "proofFiles": [ "PUBLIC-REWARD-ROWS.json", "SELECTED-PAYOUTS-VERIFIED.json", "selected-payouts-primary.json", "selected-payouts-ledger.csv", "SELF-MATCH-FEE-CHECK.json", "PUBLIC-REBATE-HISTORICAL-LOOKUPS.json", "REBATE-TARGET-MATCHES.json", "REWARD-API-COVERAGE.json", "MARKET-CONFIG-FETCHES.json" ], "priorPositiveCatalogueURL": "https://polymarket-drain-trace.pages.dev/proof/expansion-2303/self-matches/ALL-70-SELF-MATCHES-SIGNED.json" }